A Tale of Two Decades

It was a movie that should have ended halfway through. And just like that, it’s over. 19 years gone in the blink of an eye. Mike Tomlin surprisingly resigned as Steelers head coach on Tuesday afternoon after another Steelers playoff loss. Breaking down a playoff loss seems trivial at this point; the real story is the end of the Mike Tomlin era, an extremely complicated one. An era marked by huge success and major disappointment, Super Bowl victories and baffling losses. Tomlin was in many ways a victim of his own success, but ultimately also a victim of his failures and a perception of arrogance.
Tomlin was a relative unknown; he was not a big name at the time of his hire. He was the Defensive Coordinator for the Vikings at the time; his resume also included a stop as Tampa’s DB coach for their Super Bowl 37 victory. The Rooney rule, named after Dan Rooney, stipulated that NFL teams needed to interview at least one minority candidate, Tomlins hire had nothing to do with it. The Steelers had already satisfied the requirement when they interviewed Bears Defensive Coordinator Ron Rivera. The Steelers also interviewed internal candidates Russ Grim and Ken Whisenhunt. The Tribune Review initially and wrongly reported that Russ Grim was hired for the job, but the Steelers surprisingly hired 34-year-old Mike Tomlin, just the third since 1969.
Tomlin had success right away; his first season saw the team rebound from an 8-8, third-place finish to win the AFC North and host Jacksonville in a Wild Card game. Pittsburgh lost a heartbreaker to David Garrard, but it was clear the standard was still very high. Some would say, “The standard is the standard,” a classic Tomlin quote. The Steelers had an amazing 2008, spearheaded by one of the best defensive units in team history, which won Super Bowl 43. Tomlin won the Super Bowl in just his second season, some fans would claim “Tomlin won with Cowhers players.” The Steelers would return to the Super Bowl two seasons later, losing to the Packers and future Steelers QB Aaron Rodgers. He was the winningest regular-season head coach in team history, tied with Chuck Noll and finishing tenth all time with 193 regular season wins. The playoffs were a different story, especially the back half of his run.
Tomlin did not win a playoff game in the final 9 seasons of his run as HC, going 0-7 in those seasons and losing 8 in a row. For an organization and a city that prides itself on having 6 Super Bowl wins and a place that for the better part of the last fifty years experienced AFC Championship games, not good enough. It wasnt just that they lost, it was how they lost and who they lost to. Losing at home to Blake Bortles and the Jaguars, getting destroyed by the Cleveland Browns when Kevin Stefanski was unavailable to coach due to covid, getting humiliated by the Baltimore Ravens and then finally a frustrating blow out from the Houston Texans. He went 0-7 in the final 9 years in the playoffs.
Drafting and developing top talent was a major failure under Tomlin. Recent First round busts include;
Broderick Jones, Kenny Pickett, Najee Harris, Devin Bush, Terrell Edmunds, Artie Burns and Jarvis Jones. Missing on top picks and not being able to develop a Quarterback to replace Ben Roethlisberger was a key to his downfall. The Steelers organization always prided itself on smart draft picks, not drafting for a position but rather “best available”, and building for the future. None of these players were impactful and helped build to a future. Drating and developing players under Tomlin was one of the biggest factors contributing to his failures.
While Tomlin was undoubtedly a great NFL coach, not being able to sustain his early success created frustration in the fan base. In the 2025 Season fans could be heard loudly on CBS chanting “Fire Tomlin.” Even the national media Tomlin Fan Boys like Rich Eisen said that it might be time to move on. Repeatedly getting destroyed by teams on national TV finally turned the tide on Tomlin. For many years local fans were scolded by Rex Ryan, Mike Greenberg and Rich Eisen “be careful what you wish for.” Steelers fans wished for more than regular season success and playoff humiliation. Finally after one more playoff embarrassment, getting throttled by the Houston Texans 30-6, Tomin removed himself from the relationship. He deserves credit for doing something the Rooney’s would not do.
There were many high points of the Tomlin era, lots of regular season wins that seemed impossible, playoff losses that were equally baffling. Tomlin faced unfair criticism for a long time, we would be naive to discount race as a cause. Pittsburgh is an old town filled with old people with old stupid ideas. Local moron Paul Alexander has even claimed that the NFL called the Steelers and made them hire Tomlin, not even trying to veil his racism. Mike Tomlin carried himself with swagger, he would point at the camera after a big win, he was very meme-able and maybe that rubbed yinzers the wrong way. The time for him to leave was five years ago. But discounting the success he had is dishonest, unfortunately he also was frequently living in high end mediocrity. Thanks for the memories Mike.













