
Do you feel that? The rumble in your tummy isn’t a bad meatball from the office potluck, it’s the anticipation of another Pittsburgh Pirates baseball season. Two years ago a once in a generation lottery ticket fell into the Pirates lap, Paul Skenes. They have squandered that opportunity by doing nothing to build around the reigning NL Rookie of the Year and front runner for 2025 NL Cy Young. Same old buccos. BUUUUUTTTT I love baseball, it’s something about going to the park, watching the classic May or June run, and the guaranteed July collapse. I love it all! So let’s take a look at the 2025 Pittsburgh Pirates.
This team starts and ends with the starting pitching, which is not a great plan for a sport that has an offensive component. Pitching wins when coupled with hitting, it does not win alone. None of us win alone, know when to ask for help. MLB still requires teams to score more runs than their opponent to register an official victory. Coming off a last place NL Central Division finish in 2024 the Pirates of course added zero value to their team.
Big Offseason Acquisitions:
None.
Bad Offseason Acquisitions:
Tommy Pham Outfield
2024 Stats: -0.2 WAR, .248 BA, 9 HR, 39 RBI, 91 OPS+
Not good. He’s a journeyman outfielder that once punched a teammate over a fantasy football beef. It wasn’t even about money, it was because Joc Pederson was stashing players on injured reserve. Pham is such a lunatic that he handled the beef nearly 7 months later, Pham also quit said league. Total baby. I respect the slap part, but quitting the league is childish.
Adam Frazier 2nd Base/ Outfield
2024 Stats: 0.3 WAR, .202 BA, 4 HR, 22 RBI, 63 OPS+
Former All Star, yes this man was once an All Star. He was actually decent at the plate in 2021, they did the right thing and traded him when his value was high. They then did the wrong thing and resigned him 3 years later when he absolutely sucks. I dont have anything funny to write about this dude, he sucks. I was really hoping the Pirates would find a light hitting mediocre defensive 2nd basemen, they are very hard to come by and very valuable. I am sure Ben Cherrington gave some lip service about veteran leadership or something. You know who is a veteran leader? Tammy Duckworth! Maybe they should have signed her!
Spencer Horowitz First Base
2024 Stats: 1.2 WAR, .265 BA, 12 HR, 40 RBI, 125 OPS+
Pirates utilized some of their current pitching depth to acquire a first basemen, which on paper sounds great. Unfortunately Spencer Horowitz is damaged goods, he required offseason surgery AFTER they traded for him. He has some kind of CHRONIC wrist issues. From MLB.com Alex Stumpf
Horwitz had some symptoms with the Blue Jays last season, which the Pirates knew about before acquiring him from the Guardians on Dec. 10 for Luis Ortiz and pitching prospects Michael Kennedy and Josh Hartle. Horwitz, however, started to experience new symptoms as he ramped up his hitting program for this season, something that general manager Ben Cherington was made aware of around PiratesFest last month. During a subsequent examination by Dr. Thomas Graham — who had previously seen Horwitz last year with Toronto — a new injury to the tendon in his wrist was identified.
He’s 26 and supposedly ok, but he’s already hurt AND they traded Luis Ortiz for zero return. Maybe they should have just uh I dunno sign some free agents that are good?
Andrew Heaney Left Handed Starting Pitcher
2024 Stats: 0.7 WAR, 4.28 ER, 1.250 WHIP, 3.88 SO/BB
He’s an innings eater that throws strikes. He pitched 160 innings last year which is ok, he made 31 starts. Meh.
They signed some other guys and brought Cutch back just to sell tickets.
2025 Outlook
Let’s start with the positives…shouldn’t take too long. Barring an injury, Skenes will be a Cy Young candidate, he has shown in his short time that he’s a legit generational talent. He has reportedly added pitches to his arsenal and will get a full season with the big club. I would not be shocked if there is a minor regression, it’s difficult to follow up a Rookie of the Year season and a 1.96 ERA. He’s also becoming a leader, he talked about how the culture needs to change and that the 2013 Wild Card should not be the last memory of great baseball for Pirates fans. From MLB.com. Enjoy him while you can.
“We owe a lot to the city. It’s our job to go out and win for the city because this is bigger than all of us. There’s a reason why Cutch keeps coming back, and specifically to Pittsburgh. There’s something about this city. We saw it last summer. We’ve seen it in the videos of the Wild Card Game. I’m tired of watching them because it was a Wild Card Series. The bar needs to be set pretty high. Not taking anything from those guys. The fact that that’s a golden era of recent Pirates baseball, that needs to change. We owe it to the city.”
I love that. Mitch Keller is going to pitch lots of innings and probably be pretty good. Jared Jones showed flashes of greatness last year, albeit in an injury shortened year, he’s already been shut down for the first 6 weeks of the season due to elbow soreness. No ligament damage according to Noah Hiles.
The Big Question Marks
Who will hit for this team? (THIS IS THE BIGGEST QUESTION) The supposed young stud hitters have been major disappointments, 2021 1st Overall Draft Pick Henry Davis is going to start the season in the minors, Ke’bryan Hayes has zero power and doesn’t even hit for a high average (37 career home runs in nearly 500 games). Hayes also has never played a full season. O’neill Cruz has moved from Shortstop to Centerfield, I don’t know if that will help his bat. He has hit like 100 baseballs 120mph this spring so that’s something cool. Otherwise they have holes up and down their lineup and adding Pham and Adam Frazier did nothing to solve that.
Bullpen
Unless all of these guys perform above their recent past this bullpen will likely suck. Holderman and Bednar have shown that they are good MLB players, except last season. Management neglected to bring back their best reliever, Aroldis Chapman. They did bring in Lefty Tim Mayza from the Yankees, he was awful last year but really good in 2023 for Toronto. He also played his college ball at Millersville, PSAC!
David Bednar – The Renegade! Don’t boo him or Rowdy Tellez comes back and yells at you. He stinks and should have been traded two years ago when he was good. His ERA was >10 in spring training, nothing to worry about!
“I am watching you”
Catchers
Henry Davis continues to disappoint, he was supposed to back up Joey Bart but unfortunately for him Endy Rodriguez hit .321/.486/.571 in Spring and beat him out. Davis starts in Indy and Rodriguez may play a little first base until Horowitz comes back. Endy is returning from UCL injury so getting his bat in the lineup while not having to throw might be a win win. Starting Catcher Joey Bart has been Cherrington’s best addition ironically Bart was the #2 overall pick in 2018 but disappointed in SF and was traded early last season. Bart hit really well last year and will likely bat in the middle of the lineup. Maybe Davis can draw some inspiration from Bart’s career revival and learn to hit MLB pitching.
Prediction
This team will win 78 games. Another 78 win season, they have become the baseball version of the Steelers, very stale. The ownership group was handed a gold ticket and did nothing with it, you have a Cy Young candidate on a rookie pre arbitration contract and they have put nothing of value around him. Shame on them, shame on me for caring. Only an organization as inept as the Pirates could turn having Skenes as a negative, people are furious they have not added to try to actually win. It’s pathetic. They will finish in 4th place because almost all of the other teams except St. Louis are trying to win. The Cubs added Kyle Tucker who is perennially a top 10 position player in MLB, Milwaukee always plays above their roster and Cincinnati has the other most exciting player in the division Elly De La Cruz. The Pirates on the other hand run a second rate minor league operation. Enjoy some baseball!